Carrefour’s hypermarket strategy provides more operational detail but falls short of our expectations, with no format-specific sales or profitability targets. Most initiatives were already part of the Carrefour 2030 plan, while space reallocation alone may not address the format’s structural weakness in sales density. Greater emphasis on franchising and technology adoption are positives. We see limited near-term stock catalysts, with FY26 results the next key test.
Yet the short-term situation is full of uncertainty in France and the cost of riots and lootings will weigh (as announced by the management in Q3) on FY results. We do agree with Nishant that there are few catalysts to be expected before the FY results. But with a stock trading at an almost 50% discount to the European sector average, and a dividend yield north of 7%, we would buy and hold the stock until better days. This is a stock that can easily gain 50% if (when) things go right. Notably, a change in the French political landscape with a more pro-market president (who knows) would be a massive positive catalyst for the group.
Also worth mentioning in the sector : According to the FT, Asda is exploring the acquisition of another retailer, most likely in an adjacent market, with discount chains such as B&M, Home Bargains and The Range cited as potential targets. Any deal, however, could be a couple of years away.
Our view: It would be easier said than done. New CEO David Potts, a former Morrisons boss and Tesco veteran, first needs to get Asda back on track. The balance sheet is hardly supportive either, with net debt already around 4x underlying earnings. TDR could potentially acquire a target at fund level and operate it as a sister company, but shared sourcing alone will do little to address Asda’s weak like-for-like sales and profitability.
While discounters offer significantly higher margins (c.7-11% versus c.4% for Asda), the demand backdrop is challenging. UK non-food sales are flat overall and declining in stores, with clothing one of the few bright spots.
A tie-up with Morrisons looks no more straightforward, given the significant overlap in their store networks across the North of England.
For daily updates, subscribe to our newsletter and for detailed information, reach out to us at sales@alphavalue.eu